Big Q: Was a person's life path determined before they were born? Is it today? Or can a man change his stars as the clip suggests?
The first portion of the big Q is highly debatable and is largely determined by one's religious beliefs and opinions. There is also no solid proof or evidence to support or deny the theory of how a person's life path is determined before they were born. Because of this, no one can say they are correct in their view and that another person's view is wrong. However, a person who believes that one's life is determined by the one who is leading that life can give reasons that are loosely based on reality, while a person who believes one's life is set in stone before they were born, cannot.
One who says that a person's life is determined in their present situation can say that humans make their own decisions and their own choices in life, which determines their path, while one who believes that human paths are determined before their birth can only say that a greater, powerful entity decided their paths in life. Because of how critics of preset paths in life can loosely connect their reasoning to reality, due to the fact that humans do indeed make their own decisions in life that can decide their path, they hold an advantage over believers. Reality is real undeniable(though it does not directly support critics), while believers can only assume and support, based on belief. There is no proof that one's path was decided prior to their birth. That cannot be loosely based on reality, because no one has real, existing evidence of anything or anyone deciding their stars before their birth.
A person could have changed his or her current life path back in the middle ages quite easily. It is obviously quite difficult to change one's life if he or she remains living in the same area that they had been living prior to changing his or her life, in an area where most people are familiar with who he or she is, where he or she lives, what he or she does, and their physical characteristics. It would have been extremely difficult to cover up everything that her acquaintances and companions are now so familiar with. That is essentially the same as being asked to change your physique, habits, personality, routines, and even the way you talk.
The one, most effective way to change one's current path is to run away from his or her current life by running away to a different country or city. There one could have started a new, fresh life, with a new beginning, without having their history moulded into their shadow. During those times, it was very difficult to trace a person if he or she ran away from their current life. The only way to inform the public of a wanted criminal or missing person was to put up posters, and one could have easily changed their appearance through a haircut, changing the hair of their colour, giving oneself a scar, or even using a disguise in public. An example of how one can easily start a new life on their own is in the book "The Thief Lord." Both Propser and Bo ran away from Venice, and were taken in by Scipio, beginning a new existence. Though both Propser and Bo were traced, It was purely and only because they were so foolish as to not disguise themselves or change their facial image, if they had, they would have certainly never been traced, due to the fact that their hunter Victor Getz found them only by sight, there were no DNA scans or blood tests back then.
Take these photos for example:
they are the same people. It may be easy to notice when you are looking at a solid photo up close with the same expression, but back then when there were no photos, and in a busy street or at a distance, it would be significantly harder to tell they were the same.
With their entire history behind them, one could travel to another area to find a new job, meet new friends, and become someone else, different places would surely have different opportunities for people with different skills and interests. One would not have to do much more than change their appearance, so as not to attract suspicion. That could have been easily accomplished as shown in the photo above. No one would know that you used to be a peasant, criminal, or a hero. As a result, no one can be biased towards you, not knowing your previous history. At that point, it is up to the new beginner to decide what he or she would like to become, and what lengths he or she would go to in order to achieve what is desired. Because of how easily someone would have been able to cover up their history and become a new person in Elizabethean England, it is quite clear that almost anyone would have been able to change his or her current path. No one would know that you used to be a peasant, criminal, or a hero. As a result,
However, it's not the same case in modern days. Nowadays, the largest contributing factor to someone's future today is the environment around them. Friends, family, and those that are closest to a person play the largest role in their path. A person with academically excelling friends and family will
probably feel the same need to do the same thing in order to feel accepted and fit in. A person with a violent family and violent friends will
probably learn the same practices. However, there are some cases where one will become aware of what his or her future will likely look like, and they may or may not be happy with it. A person drawn into becoming a gangster could become aware of what they are going to become, and what their future and life could look like later on, and decide if they want that, or not.
In the middle ages, it was easy to erase one's history from public and start anew, easy to run away without a trace, and it would have been easy to begin a different life, but in modern times, it is much more difficult. Someone could have erased their history easily back in the middle ages, positive or negative, but in modern times, that is not the case. Today, the possibility of changing one's path is determined by what he or she is trying to morph into, and what he or she is trying to leave behind.
In modern times, if one has had a benign history, they can change into something negative or positive, without significant active intervention from others. For example, J.K. Rowling, the writer of the "Harry Potter" novel series, went from living off of benefits to multi-millionaire status in only five years. She had a benign history, so there was nothing in her history to hinder her growth. Also, someone with a benign history can change into something negative, such as a gangster, without much intervention from others in the process. It is only after he or she has already changed that they will run into life trouble. Essentially, one who has a benign history has the potential to become what he or she desires without significant hindrance from others.
However, that is certainly not the case for people with a malignant history. One who has a malignant history will certainly have much hindrance from others if they attempt to become something positive (they cannot become negative as they are already negative.)
Today, with new technology including reading fingerprints, eye scanners, and even DNA testing, it is almost impossible to permanently erase one's history. That is why a criminal will always have to be on the run, even if they run to opposite ends of the earth, even if they change their appearance, they will always have their history written in their DNA, and that's why they will never be able to start a new life without atonement for their past sins. No matter where they run, no matter how far they travel, everyone will always remember all the things they have done and been in the past. You will never be able to become a new person, and start a new life, and your old history will always haunt you. You may be able to change your appearance, but you won't be able to change your genetics, and because of it, you will not be able to change your life if you are trying to leave behind a malignant history.